Frequently Asked Questions
Is it FAA certified?
The Cool Jugs liquid cooled conversion kits are not FAA certified
and are for experimental use only.
We have abandoned any plans to certify the CoolJugs conversion
until such time as we can establish an economically viable demand
in the certified aircraft market. About 2 years ago the FAA announced
substantial additional certification burdens for piston engines
which require more than double the legally defined testing requirements
specified by FAR 33 in order to certify an engine. These additional,
arbitrary requirements coupled with draconian limits on initial
TBOs make FAA certification of CoolJugs conversion virtually impossible.
These additional burdens plus the fact that each and every aircraft
installation would also require a separate certification essentially
makes it economically impossible to produce a certified version
of the CoolJugs conversion.
Given the onerous and draconian certification issues, the tiny
number of certified aircraft produced (relative to the number
of experimental aircraft entering the GA fleet) each year and
the complete lack of interest by certified aircraft manufacturers
such as Cessna, Mooney, Solaris, Lancair, Cirrus and others we
will be concentrating our efforts on developing complete installation
solutions for various popular experimental aircraft. If you really
want advanced, liquid cooled piston engines in type certificated
aircraft then you should ask the companies that make new airplanes
in the first place. Until the OEM aircraft manufacturers believe
that there is a demand for something more advanced than 1930s
engine technology they will not offer anything else.
Please do not email us asking as to whether or not we have (or
will have) a certified version of CoolJugs or whether we have
an installation for any type certificated aircraft. We don't and
we likely never will. Also, don't even dream of converting a type
certificated aircraft to experimental or being able to obtain
a field approval for the CoolJugs conversion on a certified aircraft.
There are substantial operational limitations in both the FARs
and in internal FAA Orders with regards to converting and operating
a formerly type certificated aircraft in an experimental mode,
believe me we already know this with our Cherokee conversion.
Due to the (perceived) complexity of the modifications both to
the engine and the airframe it is highly unlikely that the FAA
will ever grant someone a field approval for a CoolJugs conversion
to a type certificated aircraft.
...and the good news?
The good news is that we are going to spend the money that we
would have otherwise wasted on FAA certification on developing
improvements for these engines that will go well beyond just liquid
cooling. We will incorporate the best of the last 50 years of
engine technology into these engines to produce the most advanced
and reliable piston aircraft engines that have yet to see the
light of day.
Is the Converted Engine Heavier and if so, How Much?
Everything possible has been done to reduce the additional weight of the conversion. First you should consider the weight of the air-cooled components that would be removed. The liquid-cooled cylinders are actually each about 1/2 lb lighter than the air-cooled cylinders. On a typical 4 cylinder engine this would amount to a weight savings of around 2 lbs. Removal of the air-cooled engine baffling usually reduces the weight by another 2 to 3 lbs for a total weight savings of around 5 lbs.
The typical system requires around 2 1/2 gallons of coolant
which, at 8 lbs/gallon weighs a total of 20 lbs. The rest of the
additional weight consists of the radiator (typically around 8
lbs), coolant pump (7 lbs), the coolant manifold (1 1/2 lbs),
thermostat housing (1 1/2 lbs), hoses (3 lbs) and miscellaneous
installation hardware (2 lbs). The net weight gain of a converted
4 cylinder engine (including a radiator) would be around 38 lbs,
9lbs of which can be offset by converting to a lightweight starter.
We feel that the small weight gain is more than offset by all
of the benefits that liquid cooling has to offer. Besides, using
9:1 compression pistons will boost horsepower on a typical O-360
engine from 180 to 195. That extra 15 horsepower more than offsets
the 20-30lbs of weight gain on a typical installation.
You should also consider the potential for significant reductions
in cooling drag that are possible with a liquid cooled engine
installation. An extra 10-15 knots is possible on an aircraft
that would otherwise cruise around 160 knots with an old fashioned
air cooled engine.
Finally lets not forget the very real fuel savings. We're not
talking about a measly 5% or even 10%. We are talking about a
whopping 38%
in fuel savings!!! However, not only do you get to save fuel
when running at full power, but you also get more power since
the combustion gases are not being cooled by running at full rich.
Will it work on a Fuel Injected engine?
Yes! Our cylinders have the necessary ports to install the standard
fuel injectors.
Will it work with a Turbocharged/Turbonormalized engine?
It sure will. In fact any turbocharged engine will benefit greatly
from being converted to liquid cooling. As almost anyone who owns
and operates a turbocharged air cooled engine will tell you -
managing the temperatures of their engine is crucial to keeping
it out of the shop. However, even the most careful pilot cannot
do anything about the even shorter TBOs that are a fact of life
on all turbocharged engines.
If you are planning to build an experimental aircraft with a
turbocharged/turbo-normalized engine you should also consider
the benefits of using a liquid cooled turbocharger. Yes they do
exist and they can offer some substantial benefits both from a
convenience standpoint (no more waiting for the turbo to cool
down before shutdown) and from a maintenance standpoint.
What is used for the coolant?
The coolant is typically a 50-50 mixture of water and some type
of glycol (antifreeze). We do not recommend greater than a 60/40
ethylene glycol water mixture. Since we require changing the thermostat
and coolant at least once a year or every 500 hours of operation,
whichever occurs first we are concerned about the environmental
impact of disposing of ethylene glycol which is highly poisonous
and non-biodegradable.
In order to protect both the environment and our Cool Jugs conversion
we recommend the use of propylene glycol in at least a 60/40 mix
of propylene glycol and water. Since propylene glycol is both
an environmentally friendly, non-poisonous and bio-degradable
substance and has unique thermal qualities it is a better overall
antifreeze compound. We are planning further testing to determine
the potential benefits of running 100% concentrations of propylene
glycols. Our only major requirement is that only non-phosphate
glycols are approved for use in our conversion. Use of any glycol
containing phosphate - no matter how little will void the warranty
and we can guarantee that your aluminum radiator will plug up
in a matter of months. Phosphates and aluminum just don't go together.
For more information on propylene glycols you should visit the
following sites.
Sierra
Antifreeze
Evans
Cooling Systems
What about the O-320 engines?
Yes, we are already planning to offer a conversion for the O-320
engines. However, we are going to wait until we sell a few O-360
and O-540 conversion kits first.
Are there any plans to liquid cool Continental engines?
Yes, we know that Continentals have their problems especially
in the valve train and cylinder head. Unfortunately we don't have
any immediate plans to offer a liquid cooling solution for Continental
engines. One of the most difficult aspects of converting a Continental
engine is finding a place for the water pump.
|